San Fernando Valley Criminal Defense Attorney

Valleys Top Rated Criminal Defense Attorney

The Use of Electronic Recordings of Serious Felony Interrogations to Prevent False Confessions

After years of false confessions and wrongful convictions, several groups have put in great efforts to research and promote that custodial interrogations be electronically recorded.

The California Commission on the Fair Administration of Justice was established by California State Senate Resolution No. 44 "to study and review the administration of criminal justice in California, determine the extent to which that process has failed in the past," and to provide recommendations and proposals which would ensure that the administration of criminal justice in California is fair.

The Commission gathered their information by studying reports from commissions of other states and tasks forces addressing the same issue, and research documenting 125 cases of false confessions by suspects who were indisputably proven to be innocent. In addition, in June of 2006 a public hearing was held in Los Angeles, to hear the testimony of acknowledged experts, the exonerated victims of false confessions, the mother of the victim of a crime in which a false confession was elicited, representatives of police, prosecutor and criminal defense agencies, and concerned citizens.

An example of this occurrence is the Harold Hall case. Hall spent nineteen years in prison for a rape and double murder he did not commit in Los Angeles. When he was 18, he was subjected to seventeen hours of interrogation, and ultimately confessed thinking that was the only way he could end the interrogation. In 2004 he was exonerated by DNA testing that proved his innocence. While in prison, he earned his G.E.D. and is now employed by the Los Angeles County Bar Association.

Some people may not believe or understand the possibility of innocent people confessing to the commission of serious crimes, but all the research provides a great amount of evidence that this really does occur and more often then people think. For this reason, the Commission created proposals suggesting that:
1. Interrogations for serious felonies be electronically recorded;
2. Cautionary Instruction Required: if a statement is admitted in evidence in any criminal proceeding and was no electronically recorded, the court will, at the request of the defendant, provide the jury with an instruction in a form to be recommended by the California Judicial Council.
3. Handling and preservation of electronic recordings of custodial interrogations relating to a serious felony.

Categories: Criminal Defense
Criminal Defense Blog
The Perfect Defense
Aiding and Abetting
Attorney Referral
Arraignment
Client Testimonials
Cross Examination
Domestic Violence
DUI Defense
DUI Of Drugs
DMV Hearing
Federal Crimes
Felony DUI
Under 21 DUI
Expungements
Hit and Run
Drug Offenses
Juvenile Crimes
Jury Trial
Obstruction of Justice
Probation Violations
Sentencing
Preliminary Hearing
Sex Crimes
Theft Crimes
Three Strikes Crimes
Warrants
Weapons Charges
White Collar Crimes
Violent Crimes
Contact Us

The Hedding Law Firm

Phone: (818) 986-2092 | (866) 986-2092
The Hedding Law Firm
Phone: (818) 986-2092
Encino-San Fernando Valley Address:
16000 Ventura Blvd #1208 Encino, CA 91436
View Map
Los Angeles-Downtown Address:
445 South Figueroa St
#2700
Los Angeles, CA 90071