Intimidating a Witness or Victim – California Penal Code 136.1

A lot of these witness intimidation cases come during a domestic violence dispute.  What ends up happening is the person that’s charged with domestic violence also gets charged with witness intimidation and ends up having to serve extra time in jail because of this. Intimidating a witness is covered under California Penal Code 136.1.

Obviously, the prosecutors don’t want individuals who commit domestic violence-related offenses threatening to do something bad to a potential witness in a case because that pretty much strikes at the fabric of the judicial system.  So, they will punish somebody who is attempting to threaten, dissuade or intimidate a witness from testifying in a criminal case.

This means they will give that person jail time and they will make that person pay a consequence for trying to prevent a witness from testifying in a criminal case and intimidating a witness — which is also known as dissuading a witness — can be of the alleged victim in the case and can also be of other witnesses in the case.

I’ve had cases in criminal court where people are arrested and charged during a hearing, like a preliminary hearing for example in criminal court, and they say something to a witness who is waiting out there to testify and another individual in the hallway or a detective will hear that and then that person will be arrested on the spot for saying something and a new charge will be added to their complaint.

A lot of times when victims or witnesses come to court the detectives come with them and they sit with them to prevent witness intimidation by defendants or any of their family members.  Sometimes family members will say and do stupid stuff in court that intimidates a witness and then that witness won’t want to testify.

So, the prosecutors start losing witnesses in criminal cases.  Obviously, this makes them very angry and they’re going to be looking to punish somebody who intimidates or threatens a witness in any way.

Closely Related to Criminal Threats

This concept of intimidating a witness also runs very closely with a criminal threat’s case.  Somebody threatens to kill somebody for example or threatens some sort of bodily harm on them or their family or somebody they know related to a criminal case, then in addition to intimidating a witness charge, that person would also be looking at a criminal threat’s charge.Intimidating a Witness - California Penal Code 136.1

And as these charges mount up against somebody, obviously you can guess the prosecutors use this to try to get long jail sentences against the person and put a bunch of bad restrictions against that person related to their criminal case.

So, if you’ve got a witness intimidation case, maybe it shouldn’t be filed against you.  Maybe it’s an over-blown charge and something can be done to mitigate it down to something less.

If you think about it, obviously an employer is not going to want somebody working for them who is intimidating and threatening witnesses.  They’re going to see that intimidating witness charge on your record and they’re going to not want to hire you.

They’re probably going to figure that if they get you in a work environment, you’re going to have some sort of an issue with either a customer, other workers or even higher-up management.

Negotiating to Get Charges Reduced or Dismissed

So, you don’t want this on your record and the way to have any chance of it not being on your record — either getting it dismissed or getting it lessened down to something else — is to get an attorney on your side who can tell your side of the story and show the good things about you — whether it be through character letters or other witnesses who might know the circumstances surrounding your arrest related to the upcoming criminal case.

So, what I have you do is, you come in.  We talk about it.  Anything that’s said between us is protected by the attorney/client privilege.  Even if you don’t decide to hire me in the case, I obviously can’t and won’t tell anybody about the discussion.

But once I get a good understanding of what’s going on and a good feel for the case and what really happened, that puts me in a strong position to advocate for you so you could end up with the best possible result in your case.

Best Defenses for a Criminal Threats Case