How are Assault with a Deadly Weapon Cases Handled in the San Fernando Valley Courthouses?
This is a good question because there’s a lot of cases centering around individuals being charged with assault with a deadly weapon. A deadly weapon can be a lot of different things. California Penal Code 245(a)(1) defines the crime of assault with a deadly weapon.
The obvious — guns, knives, but it could also be your shoe or your fist. If you hit and hurt somebody bad enough the prosecutors can mount the argument that the weapon that you’re using — no matter what it is — a baseball bat — anything can be a deadly weapon if used in such a way that it could cause great bodily injury or death to the victim.
Another big thing about assault with a deadly weapon cases in the San Fernando Valley is that these cases are typically treated as strikes. So, if you admit, plead guilty to or no contest to an assault with a deadly weapon case, you now have a violent felony on your record — a strike.
If you get any jail or prison time, that time will be served at 85%. So, the San Fernando Valley treats these assault with a deadly weapon cases pretty seriously. They are prosecuted under Penal Code Section 245.
Defenses for Assault with a Deadly Weapon
A lot of times what we try to do is first decide whether or not there are any defenses to the crime. In other words, can you make an argument that it’s self-defense and take the case to a jury trial and show the jury that you were just defending yourself.
Obviously, if you argue that you weren’t the one that did whatever it is that’s being claimed, that could be a defense as well, if they’re having problems with proof, problems of identity, no eye witnesses, etc. So, when you look at these assault with a deadly weapon cases, first you want to look to see if you have a defense.
If you don’t have a defense to the case because they have the evidence against you, then another strategy we might want to employ is to try and get a conviction for something other than assault with a deadly weapon in one of the San Fernando Valley courts.
The way we do that is plea bargain, negotiate, show mitigating factors to the prosecutor and judge and try to get the prosecutor to change the charge to a lesser charge. For example, they could charge you with Penal Code Section 245(a)(4) which is assault likely to produce great bodily injury.
That is not a strike. That can also be filed as a misdemeanor so you could get it reduced to a misdemeanor later if they’re tying to make you plead to a felony, and ultimately you could get that dismissed or expunged.
Prior Criminal Record
So, we’re really looking at the case, seeing what it is the prosecutors are claiming you did that’s illegal and then kind of assessing how serious that is. Another thing that they look at in the Valley courts like San Fernando, Van Nuys — any of the courts in the San Fernando Valley — is they’re going to look at your criminal record.
Do you have a past of doing this type of behavior? In which case, they’ll be a lot less likely to change the charge and they’re probably going to try to seek prison time against the person that has a record of this type of behavior.
If on the other hand you have no criminal record, we can make the argument that whatever happened here was an aberration. It’s not going to happen again. Obviously, one of the biggest things you want to do if one of the San Fernando Valley courts is charging you with this is get your side of the story out through your attorney.
In other words, a lot of times what I see in these assault with a deadly weapon investigation is that the police are doing a one-sided investigation. They’re not looking at the whole picture. They’re not looking to see what actually happened from both sides. They’re only looking at one side.
So, it’s our attorney’s job to tell the prosecutor — who’s the lawyer who is the one that is in charge of what is going to be filed against you and what they’re going to argue punishment-wise — what the whole story is, and if there’s some mitigating circumstances related to what happened, obviously it’s your attorney’s job to get that out to the judge and the prosecutor.
Just like your attorney in these type of cases should be discussing mitigating factors — maybe getting some character letters together that shows the type of person you are.
If you’ve got a job; if you have immigration issues — whatever the case may be, it’s your attorney’s job to grab all those good points about you and make sure that the judge and the prosecutor know about them.
I submit a lot of these in the name of a mitigation package to the prosecutor and then we sit down and talk about it and I’m usually going to be talking with the more senior prosecutor when I’m trying to resolve one of these assault with a deadly weapon cases.
I go to their office in one of the courthouses and we go over everything. Obviously, I go in there with a game plan after having talk to you about it and what we’re going to be willing to accept in order to resolve the case.
So, if you’re charge with assault with a deadly weapon in the Valley and you need help, pick up the phone now. Make the call I stand at the ready to do everything possible to help you.