What Are the Best Defenses for Medicare Fraud Cases?

Posted by Ronald D. HeddingJun 27, 2022

There are numerous laws, both federal and state, that make conduct relating to medical, health care, and insurance fraud a criminal act.

Best Defenses for Medicare Fraud Cases

For example, California Penal Code 550 PC makes it a crime for anyone to knowingly submit fraudulent insurance claims, including presenting multiple claims for the same loss and providing false information to an insurance company. In fact, this law makes it a crime to:  

  • Present a fraudulent claim to an insurance company,
  • Submit several claims for the same loss,
  • Cause car accident to submit a false claim,
  • Write any for the purpose of supporting a false claim,
  • Submit a claim for an unused benefit.

A Penal Code 550 violation is a felony crime punishable by up to five years in jail and a fine of up to $50,000 or double the amount of fraud.

In this article by our California criminal defense lawyers, we will look at this topic in more detail below.

What is Medi-Cal Fraud?

Medi-Cal is a health insurance program operated by the California state government to benefit low-income, elderly, and disabled residents.

It's designed to help people, but fraud allegations from patients to healthcare providers are common. Medi-Cal is a state-run program assisting people in accessing affordable medical care.

Conduct by people that can lead to Medi-Cal fraud charges includes receiving benefits they are not entitled to by making false statements, knowingly completing a fraudulent claim, and submitting a Medi-Cal claim for benefits that were not used. Conduct by health care providers that can lead to Medi-Cal fraud charges includes:

  • presenting a fraudulent claim,
  • submitting false information for additional compensation,
  • executing a scheme to defraud the Medi-Cal program, and
  • soliciting, receiving or offering a kickback.

What is Federal Medicare Fraud?

Federal Medicare fraud charges are covered under 18 U.S.C. § 1347 and occur when somebody willfully executes or attempts to defraud any healthcare benefit program by false pretenses, representations, or promises to obtain money or property controlled by the program.

Federal Medicare Fraud

In other words, this statute makes it a federal offense to commit fraud against a federally operated healthcare benefit program. In all fraud crimes, the primary factor Medicare fraud charges are the intent to defraud.

Usually, a federal prosecutor will attempt to prove this critical element of the crime by showing the defendant used false pretenses to obtain money or property they were not entitled to receive.

Health care providers, like doctors, nurses, clinics, hospitals, and physical therapists, are all common defendants in federal Medicare fraud cases. Other similar statutes are considered a form of Medicare fraud, including:  

  • 18 U.S.C. § 1033 – insurance fraud,
  • 18 U.S.C. § 287 – false claims acts,
  • 18 U.S.C. § 1349 - healthcare fraud conspiracy,
  • 42 U.S.C. § 1320a-7b – anti-kickback statute,
  • Patient Access and Medicare Protection Act.

A conviction for Medicare fraud will generally result in the loss of a medical license, making it difficult for a defendant to find work in the health care profession again.

Defenses of Medicare fraud frequently hinge on the intent of the accused. As noted, the healthcare fraud charge requires a specific purpose, defined as an act committed knowingly and willingly.

Are Most People Charged Employed in the Medical Field?

Yes. In the many years that I've been practicing criminal defense, I've dealt with several Medicare fraud cases, and I can tell you right now, usually, what's going on, somebody is working in the medical field.

Insurance Fraud Charges in California

They're accepting money from the government. Whether the state government, which is usually the case – or the federal government – and the government is like the mafia. 

If you're accepting money from them, you have to make sure that you don't take their money and cheat them in any way, or they will come to get you, or you have to make sure that they're getting their piece of whatever money is going on.

If you cheat them in any way, if you don't give them their money, if you underbill – if you do anything to mess with the government's money, they've got agents that will come and get you. Not only will they get you civilly, but they will also get you criminally.

So, you have to look at precisely what they're claiming that you did and, of course, what they can prove you did. 

That's why when it comes to a Medicare fraud case, I think the first thing to do if you know you're being investigated or you've been charged or you're going to be charged or you are concerned that something is going to happen, is you have to get to an attorney right away.

How Can You Fight Medicare Fraud Allegations?

Come and sit down with somebody like me.  I'm going to encourage you to be honest.  Give me all the details –the good, the bad, and the ugly.  Please don't leave anything out so I can best decide how to help you with your case.  Then we're going to look to:

  • See what evidence the government might have.
  • Do they have witnesses?
  • Do they have employers?
  • Do they have doctors?
  • What will they have to show that you did something wrong related to government money or the system itself.
    California Medicare Fraud Defense Lawyer

So, you have to get that wired down first. Once you decide whether or not you're going to fight the case because the government doesn't have the evidence or whether it's a case, we better work out some resolution because they have evidence against you; we're going sit down. 

We will map out a strategy, depending on how we answer those questions, and then we will execute the plan.  You're going to let me lead the way.

I will deal with the police.  I will deal with the prosecutors.  Never make a statement to the police if you're being investigated for Medicare fraud.  Let your attorney do the talking.  Let your attorney do the strategizing for you.

So, if you want the best if you're being investigated or charged for insurance fraud or Medicare fraud, pick up the phone now.  Ask for a meeting with Ron Hedding.  I stand at the ready to help you. The Hedding Law Firm is located in Los Angeles County, California. We provide a free case review by phone or contact form.