On January 1, 2021, a significant shift occurred in California's legal landscape. Governor Jerry Brown signed into law California State Senate Bill 384 (SB 384), ushering in a three-tiered sex offender registration system. This law, a crucial step in the state's approach to public safety, categorizes sex offenses based on their severity. The implications of this law are far-reaching and have a profound impact on the lives of those affected.
The California Department of Justice determines the tier status of registrants through a comprehensive evaluation process. This process takes into account the nature of the offense, the risk to public safety, and the likelihood of reoffending. In July of 2021, Tier 1 and Tier 2 registrants who meet their mandatory minimum requirements can petition the superior court in their county of residence to remove their names from the sex offender registry.
In California, Tier 3 sex offenders face lifetime registration and are considered the highest risk to public safety. This tier includes the most severe sex offenses, such as rape, child sex trafficking, and felony possession of child pornography. Unlike Tier 1 and 2 offenders, Tier 3 offenders do not have the option to petition the court for removal from the sex offender registry after a specific period.
For tier 3 offenders, the consequences are lifelong. They are required to register as sex offenders for life, a duty that necessitates updating their registration information with the California Department of Justice (DOJ) throughout their lives. The severity of their offense, often involving violence, force, or the involvement of children, places them in this category with no possibility of removal from the registry.
Some examples of Tier 3 Offenses include rape (Penal Code 261), sex trafficking of children (Penal Code 236.1), felony possession of child pornography (Penal Code 311.11), oral copulation by force (Penal Code 287), and aggravated sexual assault of a child (Penal Code 269).
Tier 3 offenders are automatically posted on the California Megan's Law Website, which provides information about sex offenders in the community.
They must also register with the local law enforcement agency within five business days of moving to a new address, being released from custody, or being convicted of a new offense.
With the passage of SB 384, changes were made to Megan's Law that now permit certain offenders to request exclusion from the Megan's Law website using the appropriate form.
Three-Tier Sex Offender Registry
The new sex registry structure in California, with its three-tiered system, is designed to strike a balance between public safety concerns and fairness. Offenders are categorized based on the severity of their crimes, their risk to public safety, and their likelihood of reoffending.
The rationale behind this new law is that the registration requirement for certain low-risk offenders, and the stigma associated with it, should not be a lifelong sentence. This system ensures that the punishment fits the crime, providing a sense of fairness and justice to all involved.
The tiered sex offender registry system divides offenders into three groups, each with specific registration requirements:
- Tier 1. Typically reserved for people convicted of less severe sexual offenses, such as misdemeanor indecent exposure. Tier 1 offenders are required to register as sex offenders for 10 years.
- Tier 2. This level involves more serious offenses, such as lewd acts with a minor or certain felony-level crimes. Offenders classified in Tier 2 must remain on the registry for 20 years before they may be eligible for removal..
- Tier 3. This level is reserved for the most severe category and for individuals deemed to be the highest risk to public safety. This includes convictions for violent crimes such as rape, sexual assault of a child under 10, or habitual sexual offenses. Tier 3 offenders are required to register for life, with no automatic eligibility for removal from the registry.
Failure to comply with the extensive registration requirements can result in severe consequences. California Penal Code 290 PC treats non-compliance as a felony offense for Tier 3 offenders.
Penalties for a first-time violation can include substantial fines, additional restrictions, and a prison sentence of up to three years. Continued failure to meet registration obligations may result in even harsher penalties and further damage to one's legal standing and rehabilitation efforts.
Eligible Sex Crimes
As noted above, Tier 3 is the highest risk category for the most severe sex crimes, such as the following:
- Penal Code 236.1 PC - sex trafficking of children.
- Penal Code 287 PC - oral copulation by force.
- Penal Code 261 PC - most cases of rape.
- Penal Code 264.1 PC - gang rape in concert.
- Penal Code 220 PC - assault with intent to commit a felony.
- Penal Code 243.4 PC - felony sexual battery.
- Penal Code 288.2 PC - sending harmful matter to seduce a minor.
- Penal Code 288.3 PC - contact a minor to commit a felony.
- Penal Code 288.4 PC - felony, arranging a meeting with a minor.
- Penal Code 288.5 PC - continuous sexual abuse of a child.
- Penal Code 288.7 PC - sex with a child under 10.
Requirements and Obligations
Under Tier 3 sex offender in California, there are significant legal and social consequences. The Tier 3 designation is designed for individuals considered to pose the greatest threat to the community. Thus, the obligations of those in this category are extensive and highly monitored. Let's review below:
- Lifetime Registration. For Tier 3 offenders, the consequences are enduring. They are required to register as sex offenders for the rest of their lives, regardless of whether they have demonstrated good behavior or have not committed any additional offenses. This lifelong registration underscores the serious nature of Tier 3 offenses and the enduring consequences for those convicted.
- Registration Renewal. This registration must be renewed every year within five working days of the individual's birthday. Additionally, registrants must update their information with local law enforcement whenever they change residence, employment, or other relevant circumstances.
- Residency and Employment. Tier 3 offenders are subject to severe restrictions on where they can reside and where they can work. Under local laws, certain municipalities impose "residency restrictions" that prohibit offenders from living within a specified distance from schools, parks, or other areas where children frequently gather. These limitations can make finding suitable housing extremely challenging. Employment opportunities are also limited, as many employers may be unwilling to hire someone with a Tier 3 classification.
- Internet Usage. Tier 3 offenders convicted of sex crimes involving the use of the internet may be required to register all their internet identifiers, including the names, handles, and online aliases they use, so that authorities can track their internet activity.
- GPS Tracking. Certain sex crime defendants labeled as particularly violent offenders have been subject to GPS tracking in California since Jessica's Law was implemented in 2007. In 2022, Governor Newsom signed a bill into law that strengthens these requirements.
- Megan's Law. In addition to California's sex offender registration requirements, the federal Megan's Law was passed in 1996, requiring the Department of Justice to establish a searchable Internet database where the public could view specific sex offender registrations. This law was established to keep the public informed, enabling them to protect themselves and their families from offenders deemed to be higher risk.
How a Defense Attorney Can Help
Being classified as a Tier 3 sex offender is life-changing, but an experienced California criminal defense lawyer can work to minimize the risks through several strategies as discussed below.
Perhaps we can challenge the charges. The most effective way to avoid Tier 3 classification is to fight the underlying charges. We can scrutinize the evidence, challenge procedural errors, and present exculpatory evidence to seek a dismissal or acquittal.
Perhaps we can negotiate for lower charges. In cases where a conviction seems likely, we can negotiate with prosecutors to reduce the charges to a lower-tier offense. For example, we might argue for a Tier 2 designation instead of Tier 3, which would significantly reduce the long-term consequences.
Perhaps we can minimize the sentencing consequences. Even after a conviction, we can advocate for sentencing alternatives, such as probation or treatment programs, to minimize the client's exposure to lifelong registration requirements.
Although Tier 3 offenders are generally required to register for life, we can explore other avenues for relief, such as appealing the conviction, seeking reclassification, or pursuing legal reforms that may benefit the client in the future. For more information, contact our criminal defense lawyers at the Hedding Law Firm, located in Los Angeles, CA..
Related Content:
