When someone faces a criminal charge in California, a common concern is, "How long will my case last?" Although the Constitution guarantees the right to a "speedy trial" and California's criminal justice system aims to ensure timely resolutions, the actual duration of a case can differ significantly.
Several factors influence the duration of a criminal case in California. Key elements include the severity of the charges, the complexity of the legal issues, and whether the case will proceed to trial.
Understanding the factors that influence case duration can help you set realistic expectations and plan more effectively for the potential length of your case. Sometimes, a case can be resolved within a few months; however, more complex cases may take several years. This knowledge empowers you and ensures you are prepared for the journey ahead.
Rights to a Speedy Trial
As an accused person, it is crucial to remember your right to a speedy trial, protected by both the Sixth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution and Article I, Section 15 of the California Constitution. This right gives you power and control over your case, preventing it from being delayed unnecessarily in the legal system.
California has clarified the meaning of 'speedy' under Penal Code 1382 PC. It states that in misdemeanor cases, a defendant is entitled to a trial within 30 to 45 days after their arraignment.
According to this law, in misdemeanor cases, a defendant is entitled to a trial within 30 to 45 days of their arraignment. The interval between arrest and arraignment in California misdemeanor cases is either 48 hours if the defendant was in custody after arrest or approximately ten days if they were released.
In felony cases, a defendant has the right to a trial within 60 days of arraignment, which usually occurs 48 hours to several weeks after arrest. The period between arrest and arraignment in California can vary from a few weeks to months, depending on whether the defendant is released or bails out.
A defendant can always waive their right to a speedy trial. This means that the defendant agrees to a longer timeline for their trial, allowing the prosecution more time to prepare their case. When that happens, there is no specified limit on how long the prosecution can delay bringing the accused to trial.
What Does PC 1382 Contain?
California Penal Code 1382 PC, Dismissal of the Action for Want of Prosecution or Otherwise, says, "(a) The court, unless good cause to the contrary is shown, shall order the action to be dismissed in the following cases:
(1) When a person has been held to answer for a public offense, and information is not filed against that person within 15 days.
(2) In a felony case, when a defendant is not brought to trial within 60 days of the defendant's arraignment on an indictment or information, or reinstatement of criminal proceedings pursuant to Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 1367) of Title 10 of Part 2, or, in case the cause is to be tried again following a mistrial, an order granting a new trial from which an appeal is not taken, or an appeal from the superior court, within 60 days after the mistrial has been declared, after entry of the order granting the new trial, or after the filing of the remittitur in the trial court, or after the issuance of a writ or order which, in effect, grants a new trial, within 60 days after notice of the writ or order is filed in the trial court and served upon the prosecuting attorney, or within 90 days after notice of the writ or order is filed in the trial court and served upon the prosecuting attorney in any case where the district attorney chooses to resubmit the case for a preliminary examination after an appeal or the issuance of a writ reversing a judgment of conviction upon a plea of guilty prior to a preliminary hearing.
However, an action shall not be dismissed under this paragraph if either of the following circumstances exists: if the defendant caused the delay, or if the delay was necessary for a fair trial, such as to allow time for a key witness to recover from an illness.
The Sixth Amendment and California Law
The Sixth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution ensures defendants have the right to a speedy trial. This provision prevents the government from delaying your case excessively, helping to avoid extended uncertainty or unnecessary detention before trial.
However, the term "speedy" is not defined, nor are there particular deadlines for various stages of the trial. California law, however, establishes specific timelines for when a criminal trial must occur.
- Misdemeanor cases: You are entitled to have your trial start within 45 days after your arraignment if you are not in custody, or within 30 days if you are in custody.
- Felony cases: You are entitled to start your trial within 60 days of your arraignment, whether you are in custody or out on bail.
Although the right to a speedy trial is a crucial safeguard, insisting on meeting statutory deadlines isn't always advantageous. Your defense attorney might recommend waiving this right, a strategic choice that allows more time to build your case by collecting evidence, interviewing witnesses, and negotiating a favorable plea deal with the prosecution.
What Is a Criminal Case Arraignment?
An arraignment hearing in California marks the initial formal court step in a criminal case, held after an arrest has been made. Essentially, this stage is where:
- The court will inform the defendant of their Constitutional rights.
- The defendant will be informed of the charges brought against them.
- The defendant will be given their initial chance to enter a plea.
- The court is responsible for setting, changing, reinstating, or removing the defendant's bail.
The arraignment hearing takes place after the prosecuting agency, such as the local District Attorney's office (for felonies) or the City Attorney's office (for misdemeanors), files formal charges.
This means that the agency has reviewed the evidence and decided to proceed with the case. The timing of the arraignment is strictly governed by California law.
Common Phases in a Criminal Case in California
To gain a clearer idea of how long a criminal case may last, it is useful to review the common stages involved. Each stage has its own timeframe, and factors such as case complexity, evidence availability, witness numbers, and the court's schedule can either accelerate or slow down the process.
- Arrest and Booking: If you're arrested, the initial step is booking, which includes recording your personal details, taking fingerprints, and capturing photographs. The duration of the arrest and booking process can vary from a few hours to several days, depending on the situation.
- Arraignment: During the arraignment, the charges are officially read, and you're asked to enter a plea (guilty, not guilty, or no contest). If you're in custody, this typically happens within 48 hours of your arrest, excluding weekends and holidays. If you're out of custody, you'll be notified to appear in court on a specific date, usually scheduled between 10 days and a month after your charge.
- Pretrial: These proceedings encompass motions to dismiss the case, suppress evidence, discovery exchanges between the defense and prosecution, and more. The pretrial phase is typically the longest part of the process, often lasting several months to over a year. During this stage, plea negotiations can also occur, potentially resolving the case without the need for a trial.
- Preliminary Hearing (Felony): In felony cases, a preliminary hearing determines whether there is sufficient evidence to move to trial. This typically occurs within 10 days of arraignment for defendants in custody or within 60 days for those not in custody. However, delays often occur if either party requests additional preparation time. If the judge finds probable cause, the case advances to trial.
- Trial: If the case goes to trial, it will include jury selection, opening statements, evidence presentation, closing arguments, and jury deliberation. Misdemeanor trials typically last a few days to a week, while felony trials can extend for weeks or months depending on the case's complexity.
- Verdict and Sentencing: If you are found guilty, the judge will set a date for the sentencing hearing. This typically occurs within a few weeks after the trial ends, but it may be postponed if additional reports, such as a probation report, are required.
While the above outlines the trial process, the reality is that most criminal cases in California do not go to trial. Instead, they are usually resolved either through plea bargains or by having the charges dropped.
Clearly, either option could significantly reduce the duration of your case. For more details, contact our California criminal defense attorneys at the Hedding Law Firm in Los Angeles.
Related Content:
